Member-only story
A New Take On The Trolley Problem! | Sometimes The “Wrong” Choice Is Still Right
The Dilemma: Moral Choices and Consequences
Even at the cost of actively killing someone, you should still pick this choice. Everyone knows about the trolley problem. Everyone debates between deontology and utilitarianism, but they’re misunderstanding the situation, in my opinion.
Principles and Rules
We all have principles and rules in our lives. For example, under no circumstances should we kill someone because actively killing someone that would not have died without our interference is immoral. However, if you know your actions — actively killing someone — can save five people who would have originally died, it’s still overall more beneficial from a utilitarian perspective.
The Complexity of Moral Considerations
I don’t think it’s the morally right choice to pull a lever, but I still would because moral consideration is merely one of the many considerations you have for a choice. We all try to shift the focus, not predominantly but only in reality. But in reality, sometimes, even if it’s morally wrong, we still do it.
